Register of Elders 1838 - 1918
| Name | When Installed | Dismissed | Died |
| James Duncan | | | Nov 21, 1862 |
| Joseph Blackwood | | Dec 9, 1842 | Sep 22, 1872 |
| J. S. Rodger | Oct 12, 1838 | | Jul 10, 1861 |
| Cyrus Wells | Apr 15, 1860 | to Howell Michigan | |
| Andrew Rodgers Jr | Nov 12, 1866 | | Nov 8, 1914 |
| Thomas A. Sayre | Nov 12, 1861 | | Dec 28, 1912 |
| Charles E. Walton | Apr 4, 1880 | | Nov 16, 1917 |
| J. Halsey Sayre | Oct 27, 1895 | | Nov 12, 1941 |
| L. D. Chubb | Oct 27, 1895 | | |
| J. H. Clark | Apr 1908 | | Jul 13, 1917 |
| Ross Sprague | Apr 13, 1912 | | |
| Fred Herrick | Apr 3, 1912 | | |
| John J. McWhorter | Apr 13, 1912 | | |
| Dr Fern J. Harding | | | |